Food & Drink

Reel in the Best Catch: 5 Must-Try Fish Fry Places in NYC

New York City is known for its diverse food scene, and one dish that stands out is the classic fish fry.

Whether you prefer it with a crispy batter or a light coating of breadcrumbs, there's no shortage of places to indulge in this seafood delicacy. From casual seafood shacks to upscale restaurants, there's something for everyone.

The best fish fry places in New York City have a few things in common: fresh, high-quality fish, crispy coatings, and a delicious side of fries or coleslaw.

But beyond these basics, each place puts their own spin on the dish, offering unique flavors and preparations. Some stick to classic recipes, while others experiment with spices and sauces to create something truly special.

If you're a seafood lover looking for the best fish fry in the city, you're in luck. We've scoured the streets to find the top spots, from hidden gems to iconic institutions.

So whether you're a born-and-raised New Yorker or just passing through, make sure to add these fish fry places to your must-try list. Get ready to dig in and discover some of the best seafood in the city.

1. The Smith

The Smith
1150 Broadway, New York, NY 10001 (Google Maps)

The Smith is a great spot for those looking for a tasty fish fry. The outdoor seating is a nice touch and the staff are friendly and efficient.

The oysters are fresh and the salmon is cooked to perfection.

The homemade ketchup is a standout, and the complimentary sparkling water and bread add a nice touch.

While the drinks can be a bit pricey, the food is definitely worth it. The Smith is definitely worth a visit for those looking for a great fish fry experience.

2. Make My Fish

Make My Fish
120 W 116th St, New York, NY 10026 (Google Maps)

Make My Fish is a hidden gem for seafood lovers. The fish is always fresh and fried to perfection, with just the right amount of seasoning.

The friendly staff provides excellent service, and the prices are more than reasonable.

Although the seating is limited, the food is well worth the wait. Don't miss out on the delicious cheese grits and mouth-watering collard greens.

Make My Fish is a must-try for anyone looking for a great fish fry place.

3. Lighthouse Fish Market

Lighthouse Fish Market
2451 Frederick Douglass Blvd, New York, NY 10027 (Google Maps)

Lighthouse Fish Market is a small seafood joint that offers both steamed and fried food.

The staff is polite and wears gloves for everything, which is reassuring. The food is fresh and tasty, and the portions are ample.

The menu has a good variety of options, and the prices are reasonable. The only downside is that the kitchen is small, so there might be a wait.

But it's worth it! If you're in the area and craving some seafood, Lighthouse Fish Market is definitely worth a visit.

4. LoLo's Seafood Shack

Lolo's Seafood Shack
303 W 116th St, New York, NY 10026 (Google Maps)

LoLo's Seafood Shack is a small counter-order restaurant offering Caribbean-inspired seafood. The food is fresh, flavorful, and well-priced.

The rustic shack in the backyard provides a unique and laid-back atmosphere, perfect for a casual lunch or dinner.

The outdoor seating area is charming and the service is attentive. Don't miss out on the conch fritters and the Old Bay Butter seasoning on the crab or shrimp.

LoLo's is a gem that transports you to the Caribbean without leaving the city.

5. Schnipper's

620 8th Ave, New York, NY 10018 (Google Maps)

Schnipper's is a counter-service American diner that serves up classic American fare in a casual setting.

The menu includes hamburgers, chicken sandwiches, salads, hot dogs, and fish fry. The fish fry is a must-try, with perfectly fried fish that is crispy on the outside and tender on the inside.

The portions are generous, and the fish is served with a side of fries and coleslaw. The atmosphere is lively, and the staff is friendly and attentive.

Schnipper's is a great spot for a quick bite or a casual meal with friends or family.