Food & Drink

Clucking Good: NYC’s Top 14 Grilled Chicken Sandwich Spots!

If there's one thing that New Yorkers love, it's a good sandwich. And when it comes to grilled chicken sandwiches, the options are endless.

From classic deli-style sandwiches to trendy, artisanal creations, there's a grilled chicken sandwich for every taste and budget in the city.

But with so many options to choose from, how do you know where to go? That's where I come in. As a local foodie and sandwich enthusiast, I've scoured the city to find the best spots for grilled chicken sandwiches.

Whether you're looking for a quick lunch on the go or a sit-down meal with friends, I've got you covered.

In this blog post, I'll be sharing my top picks for the best grilled chicken sandwiches in New York City. I'll be highlighting a range of different styles and flavors, from classic grilled chicken with lettuce and tomato to more adventurous options like spicy Korean-style chicken and tangy BBQ chicken.

So whether you're a die-hard sandwich fan or just looking to try something new, keep reading for my top recommendations.

1. O'Hara's Restaurant and Pub

O'hara's Restaurant And Pub
120 Cedar St, New York, NY 10006 (Google Maps)

O'Hara's Restaurant and Pub is a classic Irish bar that serves up delicious grilled chicken sandwiches.

The atmosphere is lively and welcoming, with plenty of seating available. The staff is friendly and attentive, making sure that each customer is taken care of.

The menu offers a variety of options, but the grilled chicken sandwich is a standout item. It's juicy, flavorful, and served on a soft bun.

The prices are reasonable, making it a great spot for a casual lunch or dinner. Don't miss the chance to check out the 9/11 memorabilia and photos on the walls, adding to the pub's unique charm.

2. Cheeky Sandwiches

Cheeky Sandwiches
Under Construction, 88 Essex St, New York, NY 10002 (Google Maps)

Cheeky Sandwiches is a small and unpretentious sandwich shop that offers delicious and affordable Southern-style sandwiches.

The chicken sandwich is a standout, with juicy and flavorful chicken on a bed of slaw covered in light and peppery gravy, all served on a perfectly baked biscuit.

The portions are just right for the price, and the staff is friendly and welcoming. The atmosphere is rustic and authentic, with posters and poems on the walls to read while you wait.

Don't miss out on this hidden gem for a satisfying and messy meal that's well worth the visit.

3. Stage Door Delicatessen

Stage Door Delicatessen
26 Vesey St 1st Floor, New York, NY 10007 (Google Maps)

Stage Door Delicatessen is a place worth trying for those who love grilled chicken sandwiches.

The menu offers a variety of food options, and the preparation is simple yet delicious. The service is excellent, and the staff is friendly and professional.

The restaurant also has a clean and relaxing atmosphere, making it a great place to unwind after a long day.

While the prices may be a bit higher than average, the quality of the food and service makes it all worth it. Highly recommended for those looking for a quick and satisfying meal.

4. Holy Cow

Holy Cow
34 Canal St, New York, NY 10002 (Google Maps)

Holy Cow is a fast-casual halal restaurant that serves up some delicious grilled chicken sandwiches. Their buns are high quality and the chicken is crispy and well-seasoned.

The spicy mayo sauce adds a nice kick to the sandwich. While the fries could use a bit more seasoning, they are still pretty good.

The restaurant is in a shared space with another eatery, which takes away from the atmosphere, but the service is above average.

Prices are reasonable, and they also offer vegan and gluten-free options. If you're in the mood for a tasty grilled chicken sandwich, Holy Cow is definitely worth a visit.

5. S&P Lunch

S&P Lunch
174 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010 (Google Maps)

Looking for a place to grab a grilled chicken sandwich in the city that won't break the bank and offers decent quality food in a casual setting?

S&P Lunch might be just what you're looking for.

While the sandwich has a lot of chicken, the lettuce and mayo could use some more flavor.

However, the strawberry shake is definitely worth trying. Expect to wait in line on weekends and during peak hours.

All in all, S&P Lunch is a decent option for a quick and affordable meal.

6. Cheese Grille

Cheese Grille
188 Allen St, New York, NY 10002 (Google Maps)

Cheese Grille is a cheerful cafe that serves gourmet grilled cheese sandwiches and craft beers.

The place has a cool and no-frills eatery vibe, perfect for quick bites. The menu offers vegan options, and the staff is friendly and helpful.

The grilled chicken sandwich is a must-try, and the mac n cheese is different but still good. The interior has character, and the door decor is excellent.

The location is well-situated, making it easily accessible. All in all, Cheese Grille is an excellent place to satisfy your cravings for American comfort food.

7. d Elici

D Elici
71 Nassau St, New York, NY 10038 (Google Maps)

d Elici is a must-visit for anyone craving a delicious grilled chicken sandwich. Their sandwiches are made with fresh and authentic ingredients, making them a standout in the area.

The staff is friendly and accommodating, ensuring that every order is accurate and served with a smile.

Prices are reasonable, making it a great spot for a quick and inexpensive lunch.

The menu also offers a variety of other sandwiches, soups, and salads. d Elici is a top pick for anyone looking for a tasty and satisfying meal.

8. Sandwich House

Sandwich House
17 Ann St #1, New York, NY 10038 (Google Maps)

Sandwich House is a must-try for those looking for a delicious grilled chicken sandwich. The friendly staff makes the food pretty quickly, so you won't have to wait long to enjoy your meal.

The chicken avocado sandwich is a popular choice, but the chicken parm sandwich and freshly made soups are also great options.

The prices are very reasonable, especially for downtown Manhattan.

Even though the interior is simple, the food is consistently excellent. It's a perfect spot to grab a quick and casual bite to eat.

9. Spring Street Finest Deli

Spring Street Finest Deli
322 Spring St, New York, NY 10013 (Google Maps)

Spring Street Finest Deli is a NYC deli that offers a range of delicious sandwiches, including their grilled chicken sandwich.

The staff are known for being friendly and professional, and will customize your order to your liking.

While there is no seating available, the deli is conveniently located for takeout orders. The food is always fresh and made with care, and the prices are reasonable.

If you're looking for a great grilled chicken sandwich in NYC, then Spring Street Finest Deli is definitely worth a visit.

10. Bareburger

535 LaGuardia Pl, New York, NY 10012 (Google Maps)

Bareburger is a regional chain that offers organic burgers, including grilled chicken sandwiches.

The restaurant also has vegan options and a great selection of draft beers. The service is outstanding, and the ambiance is casual and eco-minded.

The chicken sandwiches are fresh and tasty, and the brioche bun adds a touch of luxury to the meal.

Bareburger is a great option for those who want a healthy and delicious meal in a relaxed atmosphere.

11. Jacob's Pickles

Jacob's Pickles
Moynihan Train Hall, 350 W 33rd St, New York, NY 10001 (Google Maps)

Looking for a place to grab a delicious grilled chicken sandwich in a Southern-style restaurant in the US?

Jacob's Pickles might be just what you're looking for. With its good vibes and relatively new location, this restaurant offers a tasty and satisfying option for lunch or dinner.

The star of the show is their grilled chicken sandwich, which is cooked to perfection and served on a freshly baked bun. The sandwich is juicy and flavorful, with just the right amount of seasoning.

If you're in the mood for something a little different, you can also try their popcorn ice cream, which has a salty twist that pairs well with their pickles.

All in all, Jacob's Pickles is definitely worth a visit if you're craving a delicious grilled chicken sandwich in a relaxed and welcoming atmosphere.

12. Squire's Diner

Squire's Diner
80 Beekman St # 1, New York, NY 10038 (Google Maps)

Squire's Diner offers a grilled chicken sandwich that is a must-try for any sandwich lover.

The chicken is tender and juicy, complemented by the perfect blend of seasonings.

The sandwich is served on a fresh bun with crisp lettuce, ripe tomato, and a side of golden fries.

The friendly staff provides excellent service, making the dining experience even more enjoyable. Squire's Diner is a great spot for a quick and delicious meal.

13. Chirping Chicken

Chirping Chicken
355 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10023 (Google Maps)

Chirping Chicken is a great spot for anyone craving a delicious grilled chicken sandwich.

The chicken is super tender and juicy with lots of flavor, making it a must-try for any chicken lover. The prices are also reasonable, making it a great option for a quick lunch or dinner.

The menu has a good selection of sides to choose from, but the mac&cheese could use a bit more flavor.

The service is efficient and friendly, and the restaurant is clean and bright. Whether you're dining in or taking out, Chirping Chicken is definitely worth a visit.

14. Chick-fil-A

675 8th Ave, New York, NY 10036 (Google Maps)

If you're in the mood for a delicious grilled chicken sandwich, Chick-fil-A is the place to go.

With a wide variety of options, including spicy and deluxe versions, this fast-food chain never fails to satisfy.

The staff is friendly and efficient, and the restaurant is always clean and well-maintained.

Whether you're in a rush or looking for a place to sit and enjoy your meal, Chick-fil-A is a great option for a quick and tasty bite.