New York City is known for its diverse food scene, with a plethora of options for every palate. But for seafood lovers, the city offers some of the best lobster rolls in the country.
Whether you prefer your lobster roll with a traditional New England-style roll or a buttery brioche bun, there's no shortage of options to satisfy your cravings.
From food trucks to upscale restaurants, the city has a variety of places that offer this classic dish. Some places serve lobster rolls that are filled with sweet chunks of lobster meat, while others add their unique twist to the classic recipe.
With so many options available, it can be challenging to decide where to go for the best lobster roll.
In this blog post, we'll be taking a closer look at some of the best places for lobster rolls in New York City. We'll explore what makes each place unique and what you can expect from their lobster rolls.
Whether you're a native New Yorker or just visiting the city for the first time, this guide will help you find the perfect spot to indulge in this delicious seafood delicacy.
1. Aqua Boil
Aqua Boil is a seafood spot that serves some of the best lobster rolls in the city.
The seafood is fresh and succulent, and the flavors are outstanding. The cajun fries and shrimp seafood boil are also worth trying.
The staff is friendly and accommodating, and the service is prompt. The restaurant has a nautical theme and the ambiance is very pleasant.
The prices are on the higher side, but the quality of the food justifies the cost. Aqua Boil is definitely worth a visit for seafood lovers.
2. Lobster Place
Lobster Place is a seafood restaurant that offers a variety of fresh seafood.
The lobster roll is a must-try, but it is a bit pricey for the size. The oysters are fantastic and come at a great price during happy hour.
The sushi is fresh and delicious, and the Diver Scallops are a must-have.
The atmosphere is casual, and the customer service is excellent. The Lobster Place is a great spot for seafood lovers.
3. Cull & Pistol
Cull & Pistol is a must-visit for seafood lovers. This sit-down spot specializes in lobster rolls, and they do not disappoint.
The lobster is juicy and flavorful, served on a perfectly toasted bun. The raw bar is also a standout, with fresh and delicious options.
The staff is friendly and attentive, making for a great dining experience.
The subway-tile-lined interior adds to the ambiance of this seafood restaurant. Don't miss out on Cull & Pistol's delectable lobster rolls.
4. The Boil
The Boil is a seafood and Cajun restaurant that serves delicious lobster rolls.
The meat is fresh and the rolls are perfectly toasted. The staff is friendly and attentive, and the atmosphere is casual and fun.
The prices are reasonable for the quality of food and service.
If you're looking for a great lobster roll in town, The Boil is definitely worth checking out.
5. Crave Fishbar
Crave Fishbar is a seafood restaurant that serves fresh fish and seafood.
The lobster roll is made with generous amounts of lobster and is highly recommended. The restaurant also has a great selection of oysters and a raw bar.
The atmosphere is relaxed yet sophisticated, making it a great spot for a date night or a night out with friends. The service is friendly and knowledgeable.
The happy hour is also worth checking out with $1 oysters and $6 oyster pickle back shooters. If you're in the mood for seafood, Crave Fishbar is definitely worth a visit.
6. Fish Market
Fish Market is a hidden gem for lobster rolls. The Asian-inspired meals are extremely tasty, and the seafood staples are fresh and delicious.
The atmosphere is casual and unpretentious, with a fun and lively vibe.
The staff is welcoming and attentive, making for a great dining experience. Plus, the free shots of Jameson add to the fun.
If you're looking for a chill night with good food, Fish Market is definitely worth checking out.
7. Oceana
Oceana is a fine dining restaurant that offers a delectable selection of seafood dishes. Their lobster roll is a must-try for seafood lovers.
The lobster is cooked to perfection and served on a buttery bun. The dish is accompanied by a side of crispy fries, making it a satisfying meal.
The restaurant has an elegant and sophisticated ambiance, perfect for a special occasion or a romantic evening.
The attentive staff and excellent service make for a memorable dining experience. Oceana is definitely worth a visit for those who appreciate high-quality seafood.
8. Flex Mussels
Flex Mussels is a seafood restaurant that offers a variety of delicious dishes. Their lobster roll is one of the best in town, made with fresh and succulent lobster meat.
The atmosphere is vibrant and lively, making it a great place to enjoy a meal with friends or family.
The service is friendly and attentive, ensuring that customers have a pleasant dining experience.
In addition to their lobster roll, Flex Mussels also offers an impressive selection of mussels, oysters, and other seafood dishes. If you're looking for a great seafood restaurant, Flex Mussels is definitely worth a visit.
9. Mary's Fish Camp
Mary's Fish Camp is a small seafood restaurant that serves classic New England fish shack-style grub like lobster rolls.
Although the place is small and can have a queue, the lobster roll is simply amazing with real 1/2 meaty lobster. The atmosphere is casual, and the wait staff is awesome.
The menu changes depending on the market availability, but the seafood is always well-prepared and inventive.
The outdoor area is nice and perfect for a summer day. If you're looking for a seafood restaurant in the area, Mary's Fish Camp is definitely worth checking out.
10. Luke's Lobster Upper West Side
Luke's Lobster Upper West Side is a seafood restaurant that serves Maine-style lobster rolls with toasted buns.
The lobster rolls are packed with loads of claw meat and are reasonably priced compared to other places in NYC.
They also offer other seafood options like shrimp and crab rolls. The venue is small and suitable for a quick lunch, but not for a full sit-down dinner.
The Luke's Trio is a great option for those who want to sample all three rolls. The staff is friendly and the service is quick.
11. Pier 66 Maritime
Pier 66 Maritime is a seasonal destination for American fare, cocktails, and brews served on a floating railroad barge.
Their lobster roll is a must-try for seafood lovers. The roll is filled with succulent lobster meat and just the right amount of seasoning.
The barge offers gorgeous views of the Hudson River and Manhattan skyline, making it the perfect spot for a summer meal.
The staff is friendly and attentive, ensuring that your dining experience is enjoyable. If you're looking for a great lobster roll and a stunning view, Pier 66 Maritime is an excellent option.
12. Sel Rrose
Sel Rrose is a rustic-chic hangout that serves French-inspired small plates, cocktails, and seafood.
The restaurant is known for its fresh oysters and lobster roll, which are highly recommended. The outdoor seating area is perfect for enjoying a meal and drinks with friends.
The bartenders are quick and skilled, and the cocktails are delicious. The atmosphere is lively and welcoming, making it a great spot for a night out.
If you're looking for a place to enjoy some tasty seafood and drinks, Sel Rrose is definitely worth checking out.
13. Lure Fishbar
Lure Fishbar is a must-visit spot for lobster roll lovers.
The staff is friendly and the location is great, but the real star of the show is the out-of-this-world delicious lobster roll.
The interior design is nautical and theatrical, adding to the overall dining experience. It's a bit pricey, but worth it for a lunchtime splurge.
Whether you're a seafood lover or just looking for a great lobster roll, Lure Fishbar is definitely worth checking out.
14. Burger & Lobster Bryant Park
Burger & Lobster Bryant Park is a seafood restaurant that serves up some of the best lobster rolls in town.
Their lobster is fresh and the portions are generous. The staff is friendly and the service is fast.
The restaurant is conveniently located near the theater district. The price is reasonable for the quality of food and service.
If you're in the mood for a tasty lobster roll, Burger & Lobster Bryant Park is definitely worth checking out.
15. The Shadmoor
The Shadmoor is a cozy and rustic seafood restaurant that offers ample seafood dishes and craft cocktails.
With a nautical-themed decor, it's the perfect spot for a nice lunch or dinner with friends and family. The lobster roll is a standout dish that is a must-try for seafood lovers.
The service is excellent, and the staff is friendly and accommodating. The prices are a bit high, but the quality of the food and service make it worth it.
If you're looking for a seafood spot with a great atmosphere, The Shadmoor is the place to go.
16. Seamore's Chelsea
Seamore's Chelsea is a must-visit for seafood lovers looking for a delicious lobster roll. This place offers a variety of fresh fish options at reasonable prices. The service is friendly and competent.
The atmosphere is perfect for a date or brunch with friends. The oyster happy hour is a must-try, and the cocktails are great. The red curry mussels and scallop ceviche are outstanding, and the tuna poke appetizer is delicious.
The steelhead and monkfish sandwiches are well-prepared, but the open-face serving of the lobster roll is what sets it apart. Although the spinach leaf could be shredded, it's still a tasty treat.
Don't forget to try the bacon-wrapped scallops and the firecracker cauliflower appetizer. The outdoor shed seating is perfect, and the beachy digs are bright and relaxed.
17. Ed's Lobster Bar
Ed's Lobster Bar is a must-visit for seafood lovers. The menu features a variety of dishes, but their lobster roll steals the show.
The bread is warm, buttery, and garlicy, and the lobster is fresh and delicious.
The vinegary pickles on the side add a nice touch to the dish.
The service is friendly and attentive, and the atmosphere is cozy and inviting. Don't miss out on this New England-style seafood spot.
