New York City is a hub for seafood lovers, and lobster tails are a must-try delicacy. There are countless restaurants in the city that serve this succulent and flavorful dish.
However, not all lobster tails are created equal. Some are overcooked or under-seasoned, while others are simply too expensive.
To help you find the best lobster tails in NYC, we have scoured the city for the top spots. We have tried and tested each restaurant to ensure that we bring you only the best of the best.
Whether you are looking for a fine dining experience or a casual seafood joint, we have got you covered.
Our list includes restaurants that serve traditional lobster tails as well as those that have put their own unique twist on the dish. From classic buttery lobster tails to spicy grilled versions, there is something for everyone on this list.
We have also included restaurants that offer affordable options, so you don't have to break the bank to indulge in this delicious seafood dish.
So, whether you are a lifelong New Yorker or a first-time visitor, make sure to check out our list of the best places for lobster tails in NYC.
You won't be disappointed!
1. Aqua Boil
Aqua Boil is a seafood restaurant that offers a variety of dishes including seafood boils, fried fish platters, and lobster rolls. The restaurant has a marine-themed decor and nautical-themed cocktails.
The food is fresh and succulent, and the portions are generous. The menu features a variety of seafood options, including crab, shrimp, and lobster.
The Cajun shrimp is a must-try, and the garlic butter for the boil is a crowd pleaser. The prices are on the higher side, but the quality of the food justifies it.
The staff is friendly and accommodating, and the service is prompt. The restaurant is perfect for a casual seafood meal with friends or family.
2. Ocean Prime
Ocean Prime is a high-end restaurant that offers a sophisticated dining experience.
Their lobster tail is a must-try dish that is cooked to perfection. The seafood is fresh and the atmosphere is elegant.
The staff is attentive and knowledgeable about the menu. Prices are on the higher side, but the quality of food and service is worth it.
It's a great place for a special occasion or a romantic dinner.
3. Crab House
Crab House is a seafood restaurant that specializes in all-you-can-eat meals. The restaurant offers a variety of seafood dishes, but the lobster tail is a standout item on the menu.
Customers have praised the attentive waitstaff and the delicious butter lobster.
The restaurant can get busy, so it's recommended to call ahead or join the waitlist before arriving.
If you're a seafood lover looking for a great meal, Crab House is definitely worth a visit.
4. Lobster Place
Lobster Place is a seafood and sushi restaurant that offers fresh and delicious lobster tail.
The food court-style setting allows customers to order a la carte and find their own seating. The lobster roll is tasty but small, while the steamed lobster is big enough to satisfy.
The sashimi is a must-try, with fresh and flavorful cuts of fish. The oysters and diver scallops are also delicious.
The prices are reasonable for the quality of the food. The atmosphere can be crowded and noisy, but the experience is worth it for the quality of the food.
5. The Capital Grille
The Capital Grille is a top-notch place for lobster tail. The seafood is fresh and delicious.
The restaurant itself is stylish and upscale, with a refined atmosphere. The service is impeccable and the staff is attentive without being intrusive.
Prices are high, but the quality of the food and service is worth it.
If you're looking for a fine dining experience with excellent seafood, The Capital Grille is a great choice.
6. The Boil
The Boil is a seafood and Cajun restaurant that serves succulent lobster tail. The food is served in bags and the sauces are rich and flavorful.
The restaurant also offers a variety of seafood options such as shrimp, crabs, crawfish, and clams.
The mixed drinks are also good and reasonably priced. The staff is friendly and attentive.
The only downside is that the restaurant only accepts cash and can get quite crowded. However, the food is definitely worth the visit.
7. Royal 35 Steakhouse
Royal 35 Steakhouse is a fine dining restaurant that serves exceptional lobster tails. The restaurant has a clubby atmosphere and offers upscale fare to its customers.
The staff is friendly and attentive, and the service is top-notch. The portions are generous, and the food is cooked to perfection.
The lobster tails are huge and flavorful, and the sides complement the dish perfectly. The restaurant also has a great selection of drinks, including martinis and wine.
If you're looking for a place to enjoy delicious lobster tails, Royal 35 Steakhouse is definitely worth a visit.
8. Cull & Pistol
Cull & Pistol is a seafood restaurant that serves delicious lobster tail. The restaurant is owned by the Lobster Place and offers a variety of freshly caught seafood.
The oysters are a must-try and the lobster potstickers are full of flavor.
The sea urchin is a delicious appetizer and the bread is a great addition to any meal. The staff is friendly and the service is quick.
The restaurant is a bit pricey but worth it for the quality of food. The cozy atmosphere makes for a great dining experience.
9. Ama Raw Bar East Village
Ama Raw Bar East Village is a seafood restaurant and cocktail bar with an Asian flair. The raw bar offers fresh and delicious oysters, mussels, and lobster.
The Bao buns are a great supplement to the raw bar. The atmosphere is unassuming and cool, with excellent outdoor seating.
The staff is incredibly attentive, making sure everyone has a great experience. The happy hour is a great deal with $1 oysters and unique cocktails.
Highly recommend Ama Raw Bar East Village for seafood lovers looking for a great time in a fun atmosphere.
10. Burger & Lobster Bryant Park
Burger & Lobster Bryant Park is a British-inspired restaurant that specializes in lobster rolls, lobsters, and burgers.
The restaurant's location is spacious and has a happy hour. The seafood is delicious and the lobster tail is a must-try dish.
The restaurant's service is okay and the price is reasonable for the Times Square area.
If you're looking for a casual stop for lobster rolls and burgers, Burger & Lobster Bryant Park is a great option.
11. Luke's Lobster Garment District
Luke's Lobster Garment District is a counter-serve seafood restaurant that specializes in Maine-style lobster rolls with toasted buns.
Along with the lobster rolls, they also serve clam chowder and microbrews. The food is fresh and delicious, especially the lobster.
The staff is friendly and provides excellent customer service. The only downside is that the value for money is a bit low, but it's still a great place for an occasional treat.
If you're looking for a quick and tasty seafood meal, Luke's Lobster Garment District is definitely worth a visit.