Food & Drink

Slice into Heaven: 7 Must-Try Banana Cream Pies in NYC!

If there's one dessert that hits the spot every time, it's banana cream pie. The combination of buttery crust, creamy filling, and fresh bananas is simply irresistible.

And luckily for those of us in New York City, there are plenty of places to indulge in this classic treat.

Whether you're a lifelong fan of banana cream pie or you're just discovering its wonders, you'll be happy to know that there's no shortage of options in the Big Apple.

From classic diners to trendy bakeries, there's something for every taste and budget.

But with so many choices, how do you know where to go for the best banana cream pie in town? That's where this guide comes in.

We've scoured the city to bring you the top spots for this beloved dessert, so you can satisfy your sweet tooth with confidence. So sit back, grab a fork, and get ready to discover the best banana cream pie in New York City.

1. Molly's Cupcakes

Molly's Cupcakes
228 Bleecker St, New York, NY 10014 (Google Maps)

Molly's Cupcakes is a must-visit place for anyone looking for delicious banana cream pie. The cupcakes are moist, not too sweet, and come in unique flavors.

The staff are friendly and attentive to their customers' needs, making it a pleasure to shop there.

The ambiance is casual, with swing seats at the bar adding to the cool and bustling vibe.

The prices may be a bit high, but the taste is worth it. If you're looking for a sweet treat, Molly's Cupcakes is the place to go.

2. Petee's Pie Company

Petee's Pie Company
61 Delancey St, New York, NY 10002 (Google Maps)

Petee's Pie Company is a must-visit for banana cream pie enthusiasts. The pies are exceptional and the crust is buttery and flaky.

The variety of pies on offer is impressive and worth trying. The storefront is small but cozy. The service is friendly and informative.

The prices are reasonable, especially for whole pies. The pies are baked fresh all day long, and the smell inside the shop is heavenly.

For those who are not in the mood for pie, there are other baked goods and coffee available. Petee's Pie Company is a great place to indulge in some delicious pie.

3. Little Pie Company

Little Pie Company
424 W 43rd St, New York, NY 10036 (Google Maps)

If you're a fan of banana cream pie, Little Pie Company is a must-visit. Their pies are homemade and full of flavor, with a perfectly spiced filling and flaky crust.

While their prices may be a bit higher than average, the quality of their pies is well worth it.

In addition to their banana cream pie, they offer a variety of other flavors, including sour cream apple walnut and pecan.

With excellent customer service and a cozy atmosphere, Little Pie Company is a great spot to satisfy your sweet tooth.

4. Sweet Chef

Sweet Chef
122 Hamilton Pl, New York, NY 10031 (Google Maps)

Looking for the best banana cream pie in town but tired of the same old options in the area?

Look no further than Sweet Chef! This cozy bakeshop has a wide selection of pies, but their banana cream pie is a standout.

With a flaky crust, creamy filling, and just the right amount of banana flavor, this pie is sure to satisfy your sweet tooth.

The friendly staff is always happy to help you find the perfect treat, and the prices are reasonable for the quality of the desserts.

Whether you're in the mood for a slice or a whole pie, Sweet Chef is a must-visit bakery for any dessert lover.

5. Mia's Brooklyn Bakery

Mia's Brooklyn Bakery
716 7th Ave, New York, NY 10036 (Google Maps)

Mia's Brooklyn Bakery is a must-visit for anyone who loves banana cream pie. Their pies are perfectly crafted with a flaky crust and a creamy filling that is not too sweet.

The bakery offers a variety of other baked goods and treats, all of which are well-crafted and balanced in flavor.

The service is friendly and the prices are reasonable.

Whether you're in the mood for a slice of pie or a cupcake, Mia's Brooklyn Bakery is sure to satisfy your sweet tooth.

6. Billy's Bakery

Billy's Bakery
184 9th Ave, New York, NY 10011 (Google Maps)

Billy's Bakery is a popular spot for baked goods, including their banana cream pie.

The pie is made with fresh bananas and a creamy filling that is just the right amount of sweetness. The crust is flaky and adds a nice texture to the pie.

The portion size is generous, making it perfect for sharing. The cozy atmosphere of the bakery adds to the overall experience of enjoying a delicious slice of banana cream pie.

If you're in the mood for a classic dessert, Billy's Bakery is definitely worth a visit.

7. Magnolia Bakery

Magnolia Bakery
1000 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10022 (Google Maps)

Looking for a place to satisfy your craving for banana cream pie in the city that never sleeps, Magnolia Bakery is the place to be.

Known for their luscious cupcakes and out-of-this-world banana pudding, this classic bakery is a must-visit for dessert lovers.

With friendly and helpful staff, Magnolia Bakery offers a smooth process from ordering to pick up. Though prices may be on the higher side, the taste is worth every penny.

A warm and cheerful atmosphere with beautiful and delicious baked goods, Magnolia Bakery is the perfect spot to indulge in some sweet treats.