Food & Drink

Milkshake Madness: A Sweet Guide to the Best Shakes in NYC

Milkshakes are a classic American treat that never goes out of style. From old-fashioned diners to trendy milkshake bars, New York City has an abundance of places to satisfy your milkshake cravings.

With so many options to choose from, it can be overwhelming to know where to start. That's why we've compiled a list of the best places for milkshakes in the city.

Whether you're looking for a classic vanilla shake or something more adventurous, there's a milkshake for everyone in New York City.

From the towering milkshakes topped with candy and cookies to the simple yet delicious ones made with premium ice cream, you're sure to find your perfect shake.

The city is home to a variety of milkshake shops, each with their own unique spin on this classic treat. Some places offer boozy shakes for those looking to indulge in something a little more adult, while others focus on using only the freshest and highest quality ingredients to create their shakes.

No matter what your preference, there's a milkshake shop in New York City that will exceed your expectations. So, get ready to indulge in some of the best milkshakes the city has to offer!

1. Milk & Cream Cereal Bar

Milk & Cream Cereal Bar
159 Mott St, New York, NY 10013 (Google Maps)

Milk & Cream Cereal Bar is a quirky and lively dessert shop specializing in soft-serve ice cream, shakes, and bowls of milk infused with cereal mix-ins.

The ice cream is amazing, and the fruity pebbles shake is a must-try. The Cookie Crisp carnival special cone is also highly recommended.

The service is top-notch, and the menu selection is great. The prices are reasonable, and the place has a youthful and colorful vibe.

If you're looking for a unique and tasty dessert experience, Milk & Cream Cereal Bar is definitely worth checking out.

2. Ray's Candy Store

Ray's Candy Store
113 Avenue A, New York, NY 10009 (Google Maps)

Ray's Candy Store is the place to be for milkshake lovers. Their thick and filling milkshakes are a must-try.

The shop is open 24/7, making it convenient for anyone with a sweet tooth. In addition to milkshakes, Ray's offers a variety of sweet treats, including fried Oreos and beignets.

The prices are reasonable, and the owners are friendly. Ray himself, who is 89 years old, still works at the shop.

The atmosphere is cozy and authentic, and it's a great spot to stop by for a quick treat.

3. Surreal Creamery

Surreal Creamery
538 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10016 (Google Maps)

Surreal Creamery is a unique spot for milkshakes and ice cream lovers. Their menu offers a wide variety of imaginative ice cream creations served in mason jars, bubble tea floats, and milkshakes.

The staff is friendly and helpful, offering suggestions and samples to patrons.

Prices are reasonable, and portions are generous. The presentation of the desserts is Instagram-worthy, making it a great spot for those who love to take photos of their food.

Surreal Creamery is a must-visit for anyone who wants to try something new and exciting in the world of milkshakes and ice cream.

4. Sam's Fried Ice Cream

Sam's Fried Ice Cream
37B Orchard St, New York, NY 10002 (Google Maps)

If you're looking for a unique dessert experience, Sam's Fried Ice Cream is the place to go.

Their fried ice cream is the star of the show, with a variety of flavors and crust options to choose from.

The prices are affordable and the service is quick. While there may not be seating available, the delicious treats make up for it.

Don't miss out on this hidden gem for milkshakes and fried ice cream.

5. 5 Napkin Burger

5 Napkin Burger
630 9th Ave, New York, NY 10036 (Google Maps)

Looking for a place to satisfy your milkshake cravings in the city that never sleeps?

Look no further than 5 Napkin Burger! This modern bistro chain offers a variety of delicious milkshakes that are sure to leave you feeling satisfied.

From classic flavors like strawberry and chocolate to unique creations like black and white with Kahlua and vanilla, there's something for everyone.

And if you're feeling adventurous, ask for their off-menu options!

With great service and a cozy atmosphere, 5 Napkin Burger is the perfect spot to indulge in a sweet treat.

6. Van Leeuwen Ice Cream

Van Leeuwen Ice Cream
45 Spring St, New York, NY 10012 (Google Maps)

Van Leeuwen Ice Cream is a delightful place for milkshakes. They offer a wide range of traditional and unique flavors, including vegan options.

Their ice cream is made with fresh ingredients and is rich in flavor.

The portions are generous and the service is excellent. The shop has a charming ambiance and is perfect for a quick treat or a leisurely indulgence.

Whether you're a local or a visitor, Van Leeuwen Ice Cream is a must-visit for milkshake lovers.

7. Davey's Ice Cream

Davey's Ice Cream
309 E 9th St, New York, NY 10003 (Google Maps)

Davey's Ice Cream is a must-visit for anyone looking for a delicious milkshake. The ice cream shop offers an incredible selection of flavors that will leave your taste buds dancing with joy.

The staff is friendly and helpful, making the experience even more enjoyable.

The milkshakes are made with high-quality ingredients, resulting in a creamy and smooth texture that is simply irresistible.

If you're in the mood for a sweet treat, Davey's Ice Cream is the perfect place to satisfy your craving.

8. 16 Handles

16 Handles
153 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10003 (Google Maps)

16 Handles is a self-serve chain that offers a wide variety of frozen yogurt flavors and creative toppings.

They also offer sugar-free and fat-free options. The atmosphere is fun and lively, making it a great spot to hang out with friends.

The milkshakes are thick and creamy, with a great selection of flavors to choose from.

The staff is friendly and accommodating, making the overall experience a pleasure. If you're looking for a tasty treat, 16 Handles is definitely worth a visit.

9. Pinkberry

596 9th Ave, New York, NY 10036 (Google Maps)

Pinkberry is a counter-serve frozen yogurt chain that also offers smoothies and shakes in a sleek space.

They have a good variety of frozen yogurt flavors and toppings, but the downside is that the staff adds the toppings for you. The yogurt is delicious, but it's a bit on the pricey side.

They have a rewards card that gives you free froyo on your birthday and half-price off on your half-birthday.

The staff is generally courteous, and the space is clean. However, the seating area can get crowded, and there aren't always enough chairs available.

10. Max Brenner Chocolate Bar

Max Brenner Chocolate Bar
841 Broadway, New York, NY 10003 (Google Maps)

Max Brenner Chocolate Bar is a must-visit place for milkshake lovers.

With an extensive menu of both sweet and savory dishes, this eatery has something for everyone. The decor is gorgeous, and the presentation of the food is amazing.

The milkshakes are a highlight, but don't miss out on the adult beverages too. The fondue is a great sharing option, and the molten chocolate cake is a must-try.

The service is quick, and the atmosphere is cozy. If you have a sweet tooth, this place is definitely worth a visit.