New York City is known for its delicious pizza, and Sicilian pizza is no exception. This thick, rectangular pizza with a crispy crust and fluffy interior is a favorite among locals and tourists alike.
But with so many pizzerias in the city, where can you find the best Sicilian pizza?
Whether you're a native New Yorker or a first-time visitor, finding the perfect slice of Sicilian pizza can be a daunting task.
But fear not, because we've scoured the city to bring you the best places for this delicious pizza style.
From classic toppings like pepperoni and sausage to more unique options like eggplant and artichoke, the Sicilian pizza scene in New York City has something for everyone.
And with so many pizzerias to choose from, you can be sure to find a slice that satisfies your cravings.
So, get ready to indulge in some of the best Sicilian pizza in the city. Whether you prefer a casual slice on the go or a sit-down meal with friends and family, we've got you covered.
So, grab a fork and knife (or just fold it up and enjoy it like a true New Yorker) and let's explore the best places for Sicilian pizza in New York City.
1. Joe's Pizza Broadway
Joe's Pizza Broadway is an iconic pizza spot that serves up delicious Sicilian pizza. The crust is just the right thickness and the flavor is spot on.
The pizza slices are a decent size and there are plenty of varieties to choose from.
Although seating is limited, the employees are super nice and the long lines move quickly.
Joe's Pizza Broadway is definitely worth a visit if you're in the area and looking for a great slice of pizza.
2. Rubirosa
Rubirosa is a must-visit place for anyone looking for authentic Sicilian pizza in NYC.
The pizza crust is crispy and the toppings are perfectly balanced, creating a burst of flavors in every bite.
The pasta dishes are also delicious and filling. The ambiance is cozy and the service is friendly.
Make sure to make a reservation in advance to avoid the wait. Highly recommended!
3. Prince Street Pizza
Prince Street Pizza serves some of the best Sicilian pizza in town. Their square pepperoni slice is a must-try for anyone who loves deep, rich, porky flavor.
The crust is thick and crispy, and the pepperoni is thickly sliced and perfectly curled.
The Margherita pizza is thin and flavorful, with fresh basil and just the right amount of cheese.
Despite the long lines, the staff is friendly and efficient, making the wait well worth it. Prince Street Pizza is a must-visit for any pizza lover in the area.
4. Nolita Pizza
Nolita Pizza is a must-visit for anyone looking for delicious Sicilian-style pizza.
The crust is firm yet pliable, and the tomato sauce is reminiscent of traditional Italian cuisine.
The restaurant is cozy and welcoming, with friendly staff and a mellow vibe.
Prices are reasonable, making it a great option for a quick bite or a casual dinner. If you're in the area, don't miss out on this gem of a pizza place.
5. Norma
Norma is a hidden gem for those looking for authentic Sicilian pizza.
The menu offers a variety of options, but the pizza steals the show with its crispy crust and quality ingredients.
The cozy atmosphere and attentive service make for a pleasant dining experience.
Prices are reasonable for the quality of food served. Highly recommended for pizza lovers looking for a taste of Sicily.
6. Scarr's Pizza
Scarr's Pizza is a retro-style pizzeria that serves some of the best Sicilian pizza in town.
The crust is crispy on the outside and soft on the inside, and the sauce has a little kick to it. The cheese is perfectly melted and the toppings are fresh and delicious.
The HotBoi pizza is a must-try, topped with beef pepperoni, jalapenos, and Mike's extra hot honey. The restaurant has a fun and unique interior, with vintage booth seating and a bar.
Don't worry about the line, they keep it moving. If you're looking for a great slice of pizza, Scarr's Pizza is the place to go.
7. Filaga
Filaga is a must-visit place for anyone who loves Sicilian pizza. Their thin and crunchy crust with fluffy texture is a perfect combination for pizza lovers.
The toppings are well-flavored and the burrata cheese is a must-try. The pizza slices are square in shape and the pepperoni slice is highly recommended.
The prices are a bit high, but the quality of the pizza justifies the cost. The service is quick and the atmosphere is casual.
Filaga is a counter-serve stop for Sicilian pies and also serves arancini and zeppole. The place is located in Chelsea Market and is a great spot for a quick lunch.
8. Proto's Pizza
Proto's Pizza is a must-visit for Sicilian pizza lovers. Their pies are made with fresh ingredients and generous toppings, and their crust is crispy and delicious.
The staff is friendly and welcoming, and the atmosphere is cozy and inviting.
This pizzeria is perfect for a quick slice or a sit-down meal, and they even offer delivery.
Don't miss out on trying the chicken rolls and penne vodka, they're just as tasty as the pizza. Proto's Pizza is a standout in the pizza world and definitely worth a visit.
9. Village Square Pizza
Village Square Pizza is a hidden gem for Sicilian pizza lovers. The crust is the star of the show, with a flavorful cheese and just the right amount of sauce.
The pepperoni with hot honey is a must-try, even for non-pepperoni fans.
The garlic knots are also a hit. The staff is friendly and the service is quick. This is a great spot for a casual slice or a full pie.
Highly recommended for anyone in search of delicious Sicilian pizza in the city.
10. East Village Pizza
East Village Pizza is a veteran pizza shop that serves some of the best Sicilian pizza in town.
Their extensive menu offers a variety of toppings to choose from, ensuring that there is something for everyone. The crust is perfect, and the marinara sauce and cheese are just the right amount.
The friendly staff is always cheerful and helpful, making the experience even better. The pizzeria is often packed, but the quick turnaround ensures that you won't be waiting too long.
If you're in the mood for some delicious pizza, East Village Pizza is definitely worth a visit.
11. Pranzo Pizza & Pasta
Pranzo Pizza & Pasta is a go-to spot for those craving some delicious Sicilian pizza.
The pizza here is soft and fluffy yet crispy at the same time, with generous toppings that are sure to satisfy your cravings. The variety of pizza available is impressive, and the prices are reasonable.
Along with pizza, they also offer a great selection of hot sandwiches, salads, and pasta dishes. The staff is friendly, and the service is quick.
If you're in the mood for some authentic Italian fare, Pranzo Pizza & Pasta is definitely worth checking out.
12. Claudio's Pizza & Pasta
Claudio's Pizza & Pasta is a must-visit for anyone looking for authentic Sicilian pizza.
The pizza is light and crispy, with a great selection of toppings to choose from. The staff is friendly and quick, making for a pleasant dining experience.
The prices are reasonable for Manhattan, and the newly renovated space adds to the overall ambiance.
In addition to pizza, they also offer traditional Italian dishes such as calzones and pastas. For anyone looking for a great slice of pizza in the city, Claudio's Pizza & Pasta is the place to go.
13. Rosella's Pizzeria
Rosella's Pizzeria is a must-visit for anyone looking for delicious Sicilian pizza.
The restaurant offers a variety of toppings and their pizza is always fresh and crispy. The staff is friendly and the service is quick.
The restaurant also has a variety of pasta dishes, subs, and salads.
The atmosphere is casual and perfect for a quick lunch or dinner. If you're a pizza lover, make sure to check out Rosella's Pizzeria.
14. Little Italy Pizzeria and Deli
Little Italy Pizzeria and Deli offers some of the best Sicilian pizza in town. The pizza is crunchy and delicious with a perfect blend of sauce, cheese, and toppings.
The prices are reasonable, and the restaurant offers a good deal for a combo meal.
The staff is friendly and quick to serve. The only downside is that the restaurant can get crowded due to its popularity.
Despite this, it's definitely worth a visit for anyone looking for a great slice of Sicilian pizza.
